who has prepared （X）不可能变为 is preparing即没有A的意思；可能是你看错了答案。
作后置修饰语的现在分词的语义探讨
首先来看一道专四真题：
（2009, TEM4, 65）
"The man preparing the documents is the firms lawyers" has all the following possible meanings EXCEPT _______.
A.the man who has prepared the documents
B.the man who has been preparing the documents
C.the man who is preparing the documents
D.the man who will prepare the documents
参考答案：D
解析：该题考查动词的-ing形式作伴随定语的用法，含有正在进行，或者一直持续进行的意思。D答案表示将来含义，所以答案是D。
下面是我查到的一些资料：
1. CGEL(17.28)
[1a] The person who will write reports is my college.
[1b] The person who will be writing reports is my college.
[1c] The person who writes reports is my colleague.
[1d] The person who is writing reports is my colleague.
[1e] The person who wrote reports is my colleague.
[1f] The person who was writing reports is my colleague.
[2] The person writing reports is my colleague.
The nonfinite clause "writing reports" in [2] may be interpreted, according to the context, as equivalent to one of the more explicit versions in [1a]-[1f].
下面是一个例子：
You should look for a man carrying a large umbrella. [who will be carrying a large umbrella]
2.曼哈顿GMAT语法
"Comma-ing" modifiers follow on form the tense of the man from the tense of the main working verb to which they are attached.
我的问题：
首先可以看出CGEL和曼哈顿GMAT语法的讲解是不一样的。其次这个"the same tense"并没有规定是传统英语语法中的说法还是现代英语语法中的说法（现代英语语法中没有将来时，will看作现在时情态助动词）；其次很重要的一点就是这道专四真题和CGEL举的例子几乎是一样的结构，那么按照CGEL讲的，我们不应该认为D是错误答案（我当时根据CGEL的理论选了B）。所以希望各位能对此进行一下解释：是我的理解有问题呢，还是上述材料中的一部分表述有问题？
如题
请先 登录 后评论
- 0 关注
- 0 收藏，435 浏览
- 用户236478195 提出于 2023-01-30 15:27
相似问题
- 涉及关系代词的两道考题 1 回答
- well在句中表示停顿吗 0 回答
- see sb do可以加修饰词吗 1 回答
- early example 怎么怎么翻译 0 回答
- 好题分享（105）单选题 0 回答
- the best of creation成分疑问 0 回答
- pursue control in conversion mode是什么意思 1 回答
- 连词when引导的从句修饰名词疑惑 0 回答
- 反义疑问句的回答 0 回答
- 关于This washing machine has had the back and top panels taken off的表达 0 回答
- 关于feeling和leave作为状语成分，ing形式的请教 0 回答
- much是代词还是副词 0 回答
- come out ,bring out，publish(出版)区别 1 回答
- 英语作文批改 0 回答
- 关于 any, some 的一道习题 0 回答
- 高考英语选择题中it与what的辨析 0 回答